I Asked Shias About Misconceptions People Have About Their Beliefs And It Was So Enlightening

By Rameeza Ahmad | 17 Sep, 2018

Muharram has started, and for Muslims all over the world, it marks the beginning of the New Year according to the Islamic calendar.

While the month is considered holy by Muslims generally, for the Shia community, it marks a more sombre occasion.

Source: Zee News

There are a lot of misconceptions that people outside of the community have about what exactly Muharram means to Shias. And a lot of these misconceptions seem ludicrous.

Which is why I set out to ask Shias about what some of the things they have been asked or accused of by people outside their community and what the truth is.

1. A young Shia man told me, someone once told him that they had heard on Shaam-e-Ghareeban the reason the lights are dimmed at the Majlis is that men and women have sex…

He was pretty horrified when he heard this and explained that the only reason the lights are dimmed is to set the atmosphere to replicate what it might have been like for Hazrat Hussain’s family at Karbala to feel their pain better.

2. Majlis are usually always segregated!

Source: fastkakashmir.com

3. Another misconception that most Shias are tired of hearing is that they dislike the other Caliphs, which is not true at all.

Because as a young Shia woman told me, these were the men that Hazrat Ali respected so who are we to not hold them in the same regard.

4. And of course, one of the biggest misconceptions that we have all heard is that one should not accept food from Shias since it is ‘unclean’.

The reasons for it being unclean are many, a lot of people believe they put their own spit in it, they add human meat to it or that they add horse spit to it.

A Shia woman even recounted her sad experience when her classmates in 7th grade found out she was Shia.

Source: pinkingin.com

They would keep at a distance from her and tell everyone not to eat with her either.

But all of this is untrue, of course. How can someone even offer an explanation for a claim that… stupid.

Other than that, all the Shia people I talked to were incredibly open about their beliefs and even offered for people of other belief systems to come and sit in at the Majlis so that they could see for themselves what it’s all about. At the end of the day, it is all about understanding the other person’s beliefs so we can understand better and empathize.

A young Shia woman told me about how many times she had been told her beliefs were wrong and she was on the wrong path. Constantly being told that their beliefs are wrong and being called a kaafir even before they know the meaning of the word is incredibly disheartening and unfair.

Muharram is a month when Shias mourn and try to feel the pain of those who sacrificed for them. It is unfair to target them further and alienate them so that they feel even worse.

Have you ever faced discrimination in any way? Let us know in the comments.

Hina Altaf Just Broke Down After Revealing Shocking Details About Being Abused By Her Own Mother

This Reporter Covering The Grave Of Kulsoom Nawaz Is Getting A Ton Of Hate On Social Media

Cover Image Source: Firoze Shakir Poet

Share This

More Recent Stories


5 benefits of living in Islamabad and 3 downsides

10 Aug, 2022

This Is How You Can Always Keep A Part Of Home Wherever You Go

1 Aug, 2022

Hira Mani And Her Being Emotionally Correct: Why Do Cybercitizens Think She Needs Help

27 Jul, 2022

SnackVideo’s Commendable Efforts In Promoting Pakistan’s Beautiful Landscapes

KARACHI July 13th, 2022 – Fast growing content-sharing platform, SnackVideo, inspired by the vision of Pakistan Tourism Development Corporati...

27 Jul, 2022

Digital Printed Shirts By Ideas Pret – Daily Wear For Women

27 Jul, 2022

Why Do My Friends Slut-Shame Me Everytime I End A Toxic Relationship?

by Baaghi
23 Jul, 2022